What’s the moral use of AI-generated artwork?

Posted by John Scalzi on Nov 29, 2022

John Scalzi

First: the above quirk, “A peppermint kaiju in a gingerbread metropolis” drawn from the immediate by Midjourney.

Second, some ideas I’ve had not too long ago about AI-generated artwork, which I’ve posted on my private Fb account however am reposting right here to open up the dialogue a bit. I wrote:

I get pleasure from taking part in with AI-generated artwork, and in addition, as somebody who has lots of artist mates, I am involved and anxious about how this could be used to “prepare” their pre-existing artwork. How is used is qualitatively and quantitatively totally different. Human training, and the way its software impacts the livelihood of artists. Extra particularly with regard to the latter, the query is what does I Do with AI artwork results on actual stay artists.

It’s straightforward to say “no person is straightforward reply” however there are literally some straightforward solutions for me on how I can and will use AI-generated artwork in my private {and professional} life. They’re:

1. I feel it is okay to make use of AI-generated artwork for private enjoyment and visible inspiration, or to make use of it in a spot the place I can use my very own artwork/pictures or Inventive Commons-licensed artwork/pictures, and the place It has no intention. Earn a living from artwork, or one thing associated to it (like social media or weblog posts).

2. In all different circumstances, and Particularly When there’s a industrial intent or software, or after I rent an artist, I’ll search out artists and fee artwork from them. Likewise, inform artwork administrators/others that they should symbolize/market my work by way of artwork from artists, not AI technology (I do not assume I have To inform them that, not less than not due to the copyright points surrounding AI-generated artwork, however nonetheless).

As a small instance: Though I’ve a ball creating holiday-related photographs with AI, relating to vacation playing cards, I am going to flip to artwork (or utilizing my very own pictures) as a result of That is after I would rent somebody. Use the artist or my pictures. As an enormous instance, it’s doable within the close to future that I might want to collaborate with artists on initiatives, and there’s no query, for authorized, sensible and moral causes, that AI-generated artwork is the best way to go for that. shouldn’t be

The quick model is: rent artists, and make an intentional, affirmative alternative to rent artists (additionally, pay artists pretty for his or her work, not simply because I can afford it. can, but in addition as a result of it ought to solely be a baseline assumption).

I feel the AI ​​artwork technology is enjoyable. I additionally assume it requires recognition on my half that these photographs do not come out of nowhere. Ultimately, they arrive from artists. I do not need my enjoyable to offend artists that I do know, or that I do not know.


– J.S

About the author


Leave a Comment