Elon Musk calls on NHTSA to replace recall terminology: ‘outdated and inaccurate’

Elon Musk has referred to as the NHTSA’s over-the-air software program replace terminology used for recollects “outdated and inaccurate,” after the company recalled greater than one million Tesla EVs resulting from a malfunctioning window system.

NHTSA this morning issued a Security Recall Report for 1,096,762 Tesla automobiles, together with the 2021-2022 Tesla Mannequin S, 2021-2022 Tesla Mannequin X, 2017-2022 Tesla Mannequin 3 and 2020-2021 Tesla Mannequin I automobiles. The issue is with Tesla’s computerized window roll-up system. NHTSA stated: “Affected automobiles could not meet sure computerized window system necessities in FMVSS 118, Part 5 (Automated Reversing Programs). When closing in circumstances topic to FMVSS 118, Part 5, the window could function extra power than Part 5 permits earlier than withdrawing. A window can too draw lower than the gap required beneath Part 5.”

As well as, the company described the danger, stating: “If the window closes and detects an obstruction, the situation could improve danger of passenger entrapment.”

Nevertheless, Tesla will not have to convey over one million automobiles into service facilities to repair the issue. This may be fastened with a software program replace, which Tesla will ship and obtain to every affected automobile over the Web.

Musk believes the “recall” terminology must be up to date as a result of automobiles with defects equivalent to the automated roll-up window system could be fastened with downloadable fixes:

The terminology makes for a complicated description of the issue, as most individuals affiliate the phrase “recall” with an issue that must be fastened by changing the {hardware}. Nevertheless, NHTSA continued to make use of “recall” to explain these kinds of points.

Nevertheless, NHTSA stated Teslarate February that producers are required to provoke a recall for any restore, together with software program updates. Based on the company’s description, a software program replace nonetheless falls beneath the definition of a “recall.”


Tesla’s software program fixes, NHTSA’s establishment, and the approaching want for up to date recall terminology

Tesla is not the one firm battling the confusion surrounding over-the-air software program downloads and updates. Ford was in a position to repair practically 49,000 Mustang Mach-E items in June resulting from a defect within the high-voltage most important battery contactor by means of a software program replace.

I’d love to listen to from you! When you have any feedback, considerations, or questions, please e-mail me at You may as well attain me on Twitter @KlenderJoeyor in case you have information ideas, you possibly can e-mail us at

Elon Musk urges NHTSA to replace terminology after 1M unit Tesla ‘recall’

About the author


Leave a Comment